Enhance Usability: Using Heuristic Evaluation to Improve Business Interfaces

Heuristic evaluation is a type of user interface design testing that relies on heuristics or "rules of thumb." In this process, evaluators or users examine the interface and judge compliance with usability principles or standards.

Heuristic evaluation was developed in the 1990s and is used when businesses need a simple, low-cost method for identifying usability issues before products launch.

The most widely used set of usability heuristics in user interface design is Nielsen's heuristics, which consist of the following:

1. Visibility of system status: The user interface should keep users informed through appropriate feedback.
2. Match between system and real world: The interface should use plain language and use real-world conventions.
3. User control and freedom: Users should have control and freedom without having to go through an extended dialogue.
4. Consistency and standards: Users should not be left wondering whether different words, situations, or actions mean the same thing.
5. Error prevention: Design should prevent errors from occurring in the first place and provide a good error message when they do happen.
6. Recognition rather than recall: Objects, actions, and options should be visible without the user having to remember information.
7. Flexibility and efficiency: The system should cater to both experienced and novice users to accelerate interactions when necessary.
8. Aesthetic and minimalist design: Interfaces should not contain extraneous information that's irrelevant to the user.
9. Help users recognize, diagnose, and recover from errors: Good error messages are easy to understand, indicate the problem, and offer an easy solution.
10. Help and documentation: The interface should be used without documentation, but provide help and documentation when necessary to improve the user experience.

So why conduct a heuristic evaluation in UX or UI design? The businesses that use this usability testing method are looking for cost-effective ways to identify usability issues.

Since heuristic evaluation doesn't require a large budget, it's often easier for small businesses. Additionally, the process is quick and can be completed in a few days by your existing employees rather than real-world users while identifying a broad range of usability issues.

Heuristic evaluation is a simple and straightforward usability testing methodology that any business can use to test its digital products, whether an app or web design. It helps identify potential issues early in the design process while saving time and money, and it provides insights that allow you to optimize the user experience.

By aligning your product with recognized usability principles, you can develop a more user-friendly interface. Here are the steps to conduct a heuristic evaluation:

Forming an evaluation team

Before you can start user testing your digital product with heuristic evaluation, you need usability experts. You should have at least three different evaluators to catch different issues based on how they use the app and their particular expertise.

Having too many usability experts can make the process confusing, and it can lead to a waste of resources because your testers are likely to catch the same issues.

The evaluation team should be designers, developers, and potential users familiar with the interface. Having diverse perspectives can uncover a wider range of potential usability issues. When selecting your team, incorporate members who bring an in-depth understanding of the user experience and customer behaviors.

Additionally, individuals who understand your business goals are necessary to ensure the heuristic evaluation aligns with your overall objectives.

Identifying evaluation criteria

Next, you should identify the criteria you want to use in the usability test. There are many different types of heuristic evaluation criteria you can use, such as Nielsen's ten usability heuristics, or you can develop your own set of criteria, making them more specific to your product, its end users, or the industry.

In any case, you should have clear heuristics that all testers use to evaluate the usability of the product.

These heuristics should cover a broad spectrum of usability elements, such as user control and freedom, consistency, error prevention, and more. You should also consider criteria related to accessibility, responsiveness, and adaptability.

Regardless of the specific heuristics you choose, ensure they are well-defined, understandable, and relevant to facilitate an insightful evaluation that aligns with both your users' needs and your business objectives.

Selecting the business interfaces for evaluation

The business interfaces you use heuristic evaluations for could be entire applications, full websites, specific features, or particular web pages. When evaluating entire apps or websites, you'll gain an overall understanding of the user experience, which may mean assessing the flow, consistency, and ease of navigation.

Conversely, when evaluating specific features or particular web pages, you can get more specific about the user interaction with particular elements. For instance, you might evaluate a checkout process as part of a larger e-commerce website, allowing you to focus on more detailed aspects.

Conducting the heuristic evaluation

Once all your evaluators are in place and you've made your list of heuristics, you can begin conducting the evaluation. For websites, you can use sitemaps to guide the experience and give a clear view of the navigational hierarchy. For apps, you can use flow charts or blueprints.

Each evaluator should inspect the user interface independently and perform tasks associated with the predetermined heuristics. As they go through the process, they should document the usability issues they find.

Your documentation should provide context, including the specific heuristic evaluation principle in question, the issue, potential implications, and suggestions for improvement. When completed, you can consolidate these findings to identify the most critical issues.

Once heuristic evaluations are complete, everyone can discuss their findings. Every issue found should be discussed and prioritized while brainstorming solutions. The team should then compile a report to guide the design team in implementing the changes.

Severity assessment of usability issues

The severity assessment of usability issues effectively prioritizes each issue by determining how frequently the problem occurs, how much it interferes with the user experience, and whether the issue will continue to happen throughout the user of the app or website.

In addition, the severity assessment should consider the complexity of resolving the issue and whether it's simple or will require significant changes to the user interface.

Identifying common usability patterns

As you analyze each problem, you can begin recognizing patterns. For instance, you might notice there are many issues related to one heuristic compared to others, indicating a weakness within user interfaces.

If there are multiple issues regarding navigation, it may mean going back to the drawing board to find a way to make navigating the digital product easier to understand.

At the same time, you might find that error messages aren't clear and don't provide the user with the next steps, leaving them with nothing to do but discontinue the use of the product.

Identifying these patterns can help you determine which areas of the digital product need improvement and the types of improvements required.

Prioritizing usability improvements

Once you've identified common usability patterns, you can begin to prioritize improvements in a natural and logical order based on the severity assessment. You should also consider the total cost, time, and technicalities of fixing certain issues, the importance of the affected element or feature to the overall user experience, and the frequency of occurrence.

Aligning findings with business goals and objectives

You should always align your findings and actions with the business's goals and objectives. If a usability problem affects a critical feature of an app or website, it should be prioritized above the highest severity problem.

Additionally, if you have a business goal of improving the checkout process, any usability problems associated with the checkout process should be addressed first.

The impact of improved usability on business

Improving usability can boost business performance and success. Ensuring your digital products are user-friendly and work properly can enhance overall satisfaction, leading to higher retention rates and conversions.

In addition, heuristic evaluations can improve search results to help you attract and convert while providing opportunities for positive word of mouth and brand reputation building.

Enhance your usability testing with Mailchimp's marketing automation platform. Use our analytics to understand how users interact with your content by creating A/B tests. Or use our landing page builder to conduct usability tests for different page layouts, calls-to-action (CTAs), and content to optimize the user experience.