Skip to main content

How Mailchimp became the ‘heartbeat’ of High Fives Foundation

A 3‑person team reaches athletes, donors, and volunteers nationwide with segments, SMS, and expert guidance.

Adaptive mountain biker wearing a helmet and goggles navigates a dirt trail on a three-wheeled bike, with ski lifts and pine trees in the background. Stats above image are: 44.7% email open rate on annual report campaign, 14.4% SMS click-through rate, and 96% SMS delivery rate.
Published: October 2026 – Nonprofit – California, US – 146,000+ subscribers
In 2006, a ski jump in Mammoth, California went wrong, and Roy Tuscany broke his back. The community that rallied around his recovery raised money and got him back on snow.

Three years later, he turned that support into the High Fives Foundation, an organization built to give other injured athletes the same help.

Today, High Fives Foundation is a national nonprofit based in the Lake Tahoe area that has supported more than 1,000 individuals recovering from life-changing injuries. They fund adaptive sports equipment, home and vehicle modifications, and physical therapy, and run a program that brings injured veterans back to the mountain. Its community spans athletes, donors, and volunteers across the country, in disciplines from skiing and snowboarding to surfing, biking, and fishing.

Keeping that community connected falls to a marketing team of 3 people, led by Becca Lefanowicz, Brand and Creative Director. She has spent 12 years at the foundation watching it grow from a local fundraiser into a nationwide movement. And as the organization grew, so did the challenge of making sure every athlete, donor, and volunteer heard the right message at the right time.

"We use Mailchimp in some incredible ways, because it's kind of like our heartbeat," Becca says.

The challenge: One message no longer fits all

High Fives Foundation talks to a lot of different people.

An athlete waiting on a grant needs different news than a donor deciding where to give, and a volunteer in Vermont cares about different events than one in Colorado. For years, the foundation's outreach treated them mostly the same, and it showed. Getting the word out was hard, and driving donations was harder.

The team also knew that email couldn't do the job alone. Supporters were scattered across channels, and important messages—whether that be an event invitation, a fundraising deadline, or a new athlete's personal story—were getting lost in crowded inboxes.

With that small team responsible for every email, text, social post, and press release the foundation sends, there was no room for busywork. They needed a platform that could sort a nationwide audience into the right groups, reach people beyond the inbox, and offer expert guidance along the way, without demanding a bigger team to run it.

“We use Mailchimp in some incredible ways, because it's kind of like our heartbeat.”

- Becca Lefanowicz, Brand and Creative Director, High Fives Foundation

The tools: Segmentation, Customer Success Manager, and integrations

The foundation has been an Intuit Mailchimp customer since 2009, but the last few years turned a familiar tool into the center of its communication strategy.

Start with the audience itself. The team uses segmentation to divide its nationwide list geographically—East, West, and Central, plus dedicated groups for New England, Colorado, and the Reno-Tahoe area, the regions where High Fives has a physical presence. When there's news about a Vermont event or a Colorado program, it goes to the supporters who can reasonably attend.

"There's a lot going on at High Fives Foundation," Becca says. "To try to streamline and pick the right audiences, I think, is super important."

Tags add another layer of precision during campaigns. In the foundation's end-of-year “Last High Five” fundraiser, athlete challenges go to athletes and donor challenges go to prior donors, so nobody gets an ask that wasn't meant for them.

To reach supporters beyond email, the team added SMS Marketing. Texts now carry event notifications, fundraising challenges, giveaways, and the stories at the center of the foundation's mission.

"People use different forms of communication, and sometimes text messages are easier," Becca says. "Sending a large group message is very simple on Mailchimp, so we enjoy doing that."

And none of this happened alone. Becca meets monthly with a Mailchimp Customer Success Manager (CSM) who’s dedicated to her account. The CSM has helped the team build its first automation—a welcome flow for new newsletter subscribers using marketing automation flows—and led a cleanup of the foundation's audience to focus on the supporters who actually engage.

The foundation's other tools plug in around the edges. The Shopify integration connects merch sales to marketing, syncing subscriber, product, and order data so the team can message supporters based on what they buy. And the Google Analytics integration closes the loop, showing the team exactly what happens after someone clicks through one of their campaigns.

The results: Engagement at scale

When the foundation published its 2025 Annual Report, the email campaign announcing it earned a 44.7% open rate—above the typical nonprofit benchmark of 40.4%, and a sign that the audience cleanup is doing its job.

  • 44.7%

    email open rate on annual report campaign

  • 14.4%

    SMS click-through rate

  • 96%

    SMS delivery rate

SMS shares a similar story. After the team doubled its text audience from roughly 5,000 to 10,000 subscribers, their click-through rate held at better than 14%, with a 96% delivery rate. Contact list growth this significant can dilute engagement, but High Fives Foundation prevented that with strategic messaging and segmentation.

A recent campaign celebrated 20 years since the High Fives Foundation founder’s injury—what they call an "alive day." The team produced a video and sent it to its SMS list. The campaign earned a 14.4% click rate and drove more than 1,000 views on YouTube, a large audience for the foundation's channel. Roy's story is the kind the foundation exists to tell, and texting that link put it directly in supporters' hands.

These numbers have helped earn the marketing team credibility. Every campaign report gives Becca the data to show the foundation's board why their strategy is working.

"Mailchimp gives the analytics for email campaigns, and that helps us share with our board why these are important," Becca says. "With normal Gmail, we wouldn't be able to see our analytics."

A new SMS signup form recently went live on the High Fives website, and an automation to welcome those subscribers is next on the list. A/B testing is on the roadmap too, along with Mailchimp's AI tools—another set of hands for a team that could always use one.

Whatever comes next, the goal stays the same: more athletes' stories reaching more of the people who want to hear them.

"We want people to open our emails, and we want people to get engaged," Becca says, "and see all the good things the foundation is putting out right now."

Reach more people with a Customer Success Manager dedicated to your business

Share This Article